The Field Guide

Strategy

Competitive positioning without the buzzwords

A practical guide to writing positioning that survives contact with the market — not just the brand workshop.

Read

8 min

Sections

7

Words

~618

Most positioning statements are written in a conference room, agreed to in a workshop, displayed on a wall, and immediately forgotten when the next sales call starts. They're vague, internally focused, and indistinguishable from every competitor's positioning. Real positioning is sharper, more specific, and uncomfortable enough that some prospects will explicitly self-select out. That discomfort is the whole point.

Section 01

Pick a fight you can actually win

Good positioning has an enemy — not a competitor specifically, but a way of doing things you reject. 'We're the agile alternative to the bloated traditional approach' is positioning. 'We're a leading provider of solutions' is decoration. Identify the status quo your customers are frustrated with and position yourself as the answer to that specific frustration.

Section 02

Name the customer you serve — and the one you don't

Positioning collapses when it tries to address everyone. A clear positioning statement names the customer segment that benefits most from your approach and, implicitly or explicitly, the segments that don't. The latter is what makes the positioning credible. Companies that 'help anyone' usually help no one in particular.

Section 03

Lead with the outcome, not the methodology

Customers don't buy your process — they buy the result your process produces. Positioning that opens with methodology ('we use agile sprints to deliver iterative value') puts the customer to sleep. Positioning that opens with outcome ('we get your product into market in 90 days instead of nine months') earns the next sentence.

Section 04

Use words your customers actually use

Positioning written in industry jargon excludes the people who could benefit most. Sit in on five customer calls, write down the phrases customers use to describe their problem, and use those phrases verbatim in your positioning. The polish from your brand workshop is usually the thing standing between you and resonance.

Section 05

Pressure-test in real sales conversations

Positioning that hasn't been said out loud to a prospect is theoretical. Run your positioning past ten real sales calls and watch the reactions. The phrases that earn nods stay; the phrases that produce blank stares get cut. This is the single most important step and the one most often skipped.

Section 06

Make it short enough to remember

If your positioning takes three paragraphs to explain, it isn't positioning — it's a manifesto. The working version should fit in two sentences that any employee can repeat under pressure. Manifestos are useful for the about page; the two sentences are what shows up in every meeting.

Section 07

Revisit it when the market moves

Positioning is not a permanent decision. It should be reviewed every twelve to eighteen months, especially after a competitive shift or a major customer change. Positioning that worked at five customers may need to evolve at fifty. Treating it as fixed is how once-clear companies become indistinguishable mush.

The takeaway

Real positioning picks a fight, names a customer, leads with outcome, and survives contact with actual sales conversations. If it sounds like everyone else, it isn't positioning yet.

More from the field.

All articles